He is, essentially, missing a part of his identity. The narrator suggests that there are memories and experiences that take a long time to properly deal with through stories. It's worth considering the borders at play in Tridib's story: the cinema no longer has impermeable walls and borders, which means that it's now, per the logic of the novel, a place that's somewhat lost in time. This ties language to meaning and provides evidence for the narrator's assertion that Tridib's stories give him a richer experience in life—what happens here shows that a lack of stories deprives life of richness. Tha'mma evidently takes great pride in not being a refugee and sees herself as superior for escaping that life. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. It was not her fault that she could not understand, for as Tridib often said of her, the inventions she lived in moved with her, so that although she had lived in many places, she had never travelled at all. The fact that the papers don't mention things happening in another country shows how much stock those people placed in the border, as it suggests a belief that strife on the other side wouldn't affect the home front. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. The image of journey is central to the story which is divided into two section of “going away” and “coming home”. Robi reaching for Tridib suggests that in some ways, he feels responsible for his uncle's death—something that's understandable, but very much a thought process indicative of Robi's youth and lack of understanding of Tridib's relationship to May. The reason being, the narrative is so interwoven between the past and the present, with constant jumps back-and-forth, that you come to appreciate the whole of it only towards the end when it all seems to make a coherent whole, and even though I have a sense of how the story goes, I’ll only do this commendable book a disservice by writing a bad summary. The story follows a boy through his life. It took growing up and hearing May's side of the story for the narrator to truly understand the weight of what happened to Ila in her youth. Again, this shows how the narrator inhabits Tridib's stories so intensely, he can even "teach" his grandmother how to properly fly in an airplane. I used to read nonfiction usually. Get the best deals on ShadowLine Robes for Women when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. The difference between the way that Tridib's photograph looks and the way he looks in person casts some doubt on Tridib and the narrator's assessment of the photos the Shaheb took in 1939. Postmodernism in Amitav Ghosh’s The Shadow Lines 284 Coming to the characters first, most of the characterizations that take place all bear the same It’s interesting that she chooses to sleep on the floor like everyone else, as it’s a private rejection of her upper-class status, not a public one. ( Log Out /  The fact that Tha'mma is beginning to mentally go back in time to her childhood provides more evidence that she's going to regress in age and maturity in some ways. Something is very clearly wrong with Ila, and her attempts to hide it suggest that whatever is wrong is embarrassing and possibly threatens her sense of self or social standing—things that she very much takes for granted. The Shadow Lines is a powerful, captivating story told by an unseen narrator who relies on bits and pieces of his memory to piece the events together. For Tha'mma, the difference between her memory of Dhaka and what she sees now is disturbing and makes her feel disconnected from her past. This woman's lot in life shows that Tha'mma was deeply ignorant about her own family. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.”. Newspapers there insisted that the theft of the relic was part of a conspiracy and an attack on Muslims. Finally, Ila admits that she relies on stories as much as the narrator does to influence her reality—though she does so by telling untrue stories to change how the narrator thought of her. The relic was recovered on January 4, and Srinagar celebrated. In fact, as has been mentioned earlier, to call Ghosh’s novel as mere political allegory would be facile. When a mob shows that it is willing to approach and possibly attack a school bus filled with innocent children, it's a sinister reminder that these riots are nonsensical, unpredictable, and incredibly violent. The narrator's aside suggests that the Shaheb might not be an alcoholic at all; instead, it might be a convenient story for Tha'mma to tell herself so that she doesn't have to accept that her brother-in-law isn't as wonderful as she expected. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. The shadow can only be seen to the right of an unlit face of the object. For one, the house's initial divisions seem to have disappeared, given that the Muslim Khalil is caring for the Hindu Jethamoshai. Finally. The Shadow Lines Quotes Showing 1-15 of 15 “[T]hat state, love, is so utterly alien to that other idea without which we cannot live as human beings --- the idea of justice. I told her we had to try because the alternative wasn’t blankness — it only meant that if we didn’t try ourselves, we would never be free of other people’s inventions. After coming back, the narrator meets with Captain Giles and talks about not belonging to the youth shadow line anymore. By telling this part of the story from Robi's perspective, the narrator is able to cultivate the sense that the violence that met them was expected, just not by a naïve and youthful child. We were on our way to Dehradun from the ISBT at Kashmere Gate, Delhi. Again, this illustrates that because Tha'mma didn't experience this herself, it doesn't feel truly real for her—while Dhaka does. Ghosh makes shadow lines an interesting read. Immediately download the The Shadow Line summary, chapter-by-chapter analysis, book notes, essays, quotes, character descriptions, lesson plans, and more - everything you need for studying or teaching The Shadow Line. The fact that the boys can pick up on this and interpret this shows that they do have the capacity to think critically and in a more adult way about the conflict. Again, this suggests that Ila lives entirely in the present, and she doesn't allow her memories of the past or thoughts about the future to inform her life in any way. By Nishant Bana Amitav Ghosh was born in Calcutta and grew up in India, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.He studied in Delhi, Oxford and Alexandria and is the author of The Circle of Reason, The Shadow Lines, In An Antique Land, Dancing in Cambodia, The Calcutta Chromosome, The Glass Palace, The Hungry Tide, and Sea of Poppies, which is the first volume of a projected series of novels, The … The Shadow Lines Summary. Notice that the lack of speech between the two sides is very much what kept the feud going: this suggests that stories and speech are possibly a way to combat anger and violence and potentially, to bridge the gap. Going Away. I don’t remember how our conversation really started, but soon enough I was chatting with her about my predicament — how I was unsure of my future plans, and what could she tell me about Delhi University? When she is nearing her death, and the narrator is by her bedside, this is how he feels for her: my heart fills with love for her — love and that other thing, which is not pity but something else, something the English language knows only in its absence — ruth — a tenderness which is not merely pity and not only love. Synopsis:Rotten Tomatoes, home of the Tomatometer, is the most trusted measurement of quality for Movies & TV. Victoria Winters (Alexandre Moltke) arrives via train at the small coastal fishing town of Collinsport, Maine. There is no point of reference to hold on to. This issue becomes more pertinent when viewed in the context of the Partition of the Indian subcontinent. Her uncertainty, however, also points to her own youth and the fact that she's unsure whether Tridib is a skilled storyteller or an actual romantic partner. Several months after he makes these discoveries, the. The narrator's assessment of what's happening shows that political unrest often doesn't make much sense at the time; it's just terrifying. Summary Of The Shadow Lines By Amitav Ghosh. The Shadow Lines is one of Ghosh's earlier books, which speaks of the early brilliance of this author. Essentially, the narrator proposes that the role of the government is to make citizens loyal to the nation, rather than to people that they have intimate and friendly relationships with but that the government labels as "other." This moment points back to when the narrator touched Ila without permission when they were children. Gems like those are scattered all over the book, and I point out a few only to nudge the reader into picking up the book and reading it — also, to point out a few themes that make The Shadow Lines a meditation of sorts: on seeing the world, on the arbitrariness of national boundaries, on love and on nostalgia. Ila appears somewhat hypocritical, as she views the world through an arguably even more naïve lens than May does. The story begins in … In this moment, Tha’mma also comes to the realization that the Partition of India affects her sense of identity more than she previously realized. When May can't quite figure out how she feels about the letter but errs on the side of finding it intriguing, it shows again that Tridib was successful in using storytelling and memory to alter how May thinks about her lived reality. The fact that he's doing the same here to May suggests that even if he is in some ways considered lesser because he's Indian and only middle class, the fact that he's male does afford him power, which he abuses. Tha'mma's uncertainty stems from the sudden realization that Dhaka in the present is certainly not like the Dhaka she remembers. Page 141-160 Summary . The memories begin in the early twentieth century when Tridib's grandfather, Mr. Justice Chandrashekhar Datta-Chaudhuri, … His privilege allows him to see the trouble as something that happens to other, less fortunate people. The recurring nightmare means that Robi will never be free from the political violence of 1964, as there's no way for him to achieve closure of any sort. The narrator realizes suddenly that. The story cleverly engages in its main body characters spanning three generations of this family. Again, memories, this time in the form of old borders, continue to inform the present. The teacher is clearly trying to maintain a sense of calm and order in her classroom by insisting that nothing is wrong—the students are well aware that something is afoot, even if they're not sure what. When the. Further, notice how the riots are stoked in part by the assertion that there are religious tensions; this shows that this story can be used to shape reality. It stars Chiwetel Ejiofor, Christopher Eccleston, Rafe Spall, Lesley Sharp, Kierston Wareing, Antony Sher and Stephen Rea.The series was written, directed and produced by Hugo Blick.. I think a book too has to be invented while you’re reading it, and if you don’t do that, you won’t be free of the inventions of others. This echoes the way that Ila once told the narrator a story about her doll being bullied, when in reality, Ila was the one being bullied by racist kids at school. The Shadow Lines: Going Away, and Coming Home. The story sounds fantastical, and it preserves the sense that Tridib's stories of memories are far more important to the narrator than these fantasy stories—especially since the narrator does, at points, forget the story. Especially when she's banned from visiting the school, Tha'mma must truly find out how define herself as something other than as a teacher or as a headmistress. And equally we may find the opposite. This only feeds the boys' fear, as everything they know about their world is suddenly turned on its head. I could relate to that story of hers and since I didn’t want to drop a year before realizing what I wanted to do, I sort of figured I should give physics a try and decided to apply to Delhi University that summer. There are riots throughout India due to how British partitioned the country. Notably, this instance of casual sex relies on these two people letting down their personal boundaries in a similarly boundless space—again, suggesting there's value in. In Joseph Conrad's ''The Shadow Line'', the author explores the passage to manhood. Before he departs he writes a recommendation letter for Ransome and wearily watches the good but troubled man leave. The fact that May recognizes that she was very young at this point allows the reader to read her actions during her visit to India as being young and possibly misguided. By treating May with this kind of deference, it suggests he believes it's still a period in time when the British were people to revere in India. Instead what Ghosh shows is the impact of politics on the lives of ordinary people and on human relationship. Again, this mirrors the way that the narrator uses his own memories and Tridib's stories to provide greater meaning and richness to his experiences. In his old age, Jethamoshai lives entirely in his memories, especially given that he doesn't seem to even be aware of when in time he is. During the 1950s, Helsinki was the focal point of the Cold War, as global powers and their intelligence agencies coalesced in the small neutral country that stood between the East and the West. Again, even more important than climbing the social ladder is stressing the fact that a person is higher up on the social ladder than someone else—and trying not to slip, Inside, the relative serves tea and tells. Again, this wall through the house mirrors the lines drawn during Partition, which were also drawn in seemingly strange places given the ethnic and religious makeup of the regions that were divided. It is a book that captures perspective of time and events, of lines that bring people together and hold them apart; lines that are clearly visible from one perspective and nonexistent from another; lines that exist … Instead what Ghosh shows is the impact of politics on the lives of ordinary people and on human relationship. Teachers and parents! The Shadow Lines Questions and Answers - Discover the eNotes.com community of teachers, mentors and students just like you that can answer any question you might have on The Shadow Lines The realization that a family member lives like this is likely shocking for Tha'mma, who has spent decades of her life associating only with Mayadebi and her wealthy family and lifestyle. -Graham S. The switch in power from Tha'mma to the narrator's mother suggests that Tha'mma's identity change in her old age may be a growing down of sorts, given that she's now giving up her power and status. Change ). On another occasion the narrator meditates on the love he inadvertently feels for Ila: that state, love, is so utterly alien to that other idea without which we cannot live as human beings — the idea of justice. The Shadow Lines (1988) is a Sahitya Akademi Award -winning novel by Indian writer Amitav Ghosh. Ila and Nick's plans and the gifts they receive are indicative of their social standing and make it clear that Ila has no intention of returning to India. ( Log Out /  The reality of the house continues to not match up with what Tha'mma remembers. … And things which did not fit my vocabulary were merely pushed over the edge into the chasm of that silence. Infidelity exists the world over, and being "free" in London doesn't free her from unfortunate truths like that. Our, LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in. His insistence that they're evil suggests that he's spent his time telling himself stories about his family that support his hatred of them. The Shadow Lines is a novel about a boy and his family. The Narrator reflects on his grandmother. As the conflict progresses, stories have a negative effect: the rumors only stoke the fear of the "other," which in turn leads to violence. Thus the going away - the title of the first section of the novel - becomes coming home - the title of the second section. The narrator was born and raised in Calcutta, India, but he has friends and family who live in London, England. July 31, 2012. tags: amitav ghosh, book review, books, silence, the shadow lines. This suggests that he hasn't had to come to grips with the violence of the city, which forever changed Robi's life and soured his memories of the city. Tha'mma's first few months in retirement are very much a coming of age experience for her: she has to figure out how to exist in this new phase of life, just as a child learns how to become an adult. If I were to make an attempt at sketching the story of The Shadow Lines in a few words, I would not do a good job of it. She identifies as an Indian and Hindu woman, but in this moment, she realizes that because of the borders, she wasn’t technically born in India—she’s from the Muslim-majority country of East Pakistan. As May predicted, the narrator feels horrible about his actions—her story became his reality, and now he must live with the memory of his bad behavior. And if at all ‘book reviews’ of this sort can be dedicated to anyone, I dedicate it to that fellow traveller on that bus ride back home. I never met her again after that bus ride. Ghosh makes shadow lines an interesting read. The fact that she looks down on Indian refugees from Pakistan suggests that her desire for freedom and the border is complicated, given that she seems to not believe that people should be able to live in the country that aligns most closely with their religious identity (India and Pakistan were divided along religious lines). Storyline. The black line cannot possible be a shadow. This shows that the governments as the narrator conceptualizes them were successful in their endeavors to make people more loyal to what's happening inside their country's borders than anything outside. The effect that this letter has on May suggests that Tridib was effective in making the letter, which is a memory, real for her as well—and in doing so, augmenting her reality and making it richer through stories and memories. Tridib’s comment about Tha’mma being a foreigner point to the way that the Partition of India altered Tha’mma’s identity as an Indian and Hindu woman—now, even her hometown feels different. However, this slip of language alludes to the power of stories and the way in which people describe themselves and their homes: Tha'mma has the power to dictate where home is by changing whether she's coming or going home to a place. The desire to fix what happened in the past shows Tha'mma returning to her childhood memories and, essentially, bringing them back up to challenge how real they actually are. So when I finished reading it this summer and reflected upon what I had read, I realized it was a really good recommendation from that fellow traveller of yore. The governments of India and Pakistan were both outraged and apparently did what they could to stop the riots. In its simplest form, the story is about a young boy in India (who is the narrator). 256. However, in doing so, there's also the possibility that Tha'mma's memories will no longer seem as right or powerful. Summary Of The Shadow Lines By Amitav Ghosh. At eleven, the narrator is still very naïve and is unaware of May and Tridib’s relationship and how they exchanged photographs of each other several years before this visit. When Tridib invites the narrator along to the train station, it indicates that the two have a strong and loving relationship with each other—though over the course of May's visit, the narrator will question this. When Tridib was eight years old, they left Calcutta to go to England in 1939. Instead, I shall just write about a few things that caught my attention and which I think I should share. The novel is divided into two parts; “Going away” and “coming home” and therefore portrays the image of a journey. In her lived experience, borders and walls are real, tangible, visible things, so she’s confused that the border between India and East Pakistan isn’t the same way. The juxtaposition of this possibly emotional and heartfelt moment for Tha'mma with the possibility of violence suggests that sometimes, returning to one's old memories is fraught—things change, and not always for the better. Jethamoshai hasn't even seen Tha'mma and Mayadebi since they were children. This would also lead to a renewal of youthful beliefs. LitCharts Teacher Editions. When the narrator's father mentions the possibility of trouble, it makes it clear that the adults surrounding the narrator have information he doesn't—he'll experience what's to come as a child, with very limited information and a naïve understanding of the world around him. The narrator didn't understand that the bullying story Ila told him in their childhood actually happened to her. The fact that she still ruminates on what happened shows how her youth continues to influence how she thinks about and moves through the world as an adult, especially since she apparently fixates on her unwillingness to fully return Tridib's love. It's worth noting that the small-scale events of this one house very much mirror the larger-scale events of Partition: violence and suspicion escalated, even though there had once been harmony between the different groups in British India. The narrator's youthful understanding of the world he lives in means that he thinks of his mother's interest in the news as being indicative of her worldliness and engagement with politics—not a simple way to make sure her family stays safe from the riots that gripped India at this point in time. That which, on surface, is projected as completely opposed to another is actually a part of it. We were on our way to Dehradun from the ISBT at Kashmere Gate, Delhi. Casting shadow on the table. By now relaying the story to May, the novel shows again how childhood and adulthood continue to inform each other and shape how they play out. As before, the narrator sees his memories and Tridib's memories as layered one on top of the other, all informing each other in various ways. In this way, he finally is able to use stories to add meaning to his experience and his memory, and further, to connect his memory with other people’s memories (namely, Robi's). This is, presumably, a defining moment in Tridib's own coming of age—at the very least, since he's telling the story to May, it's something that has stuck with him and informed his experiences as an adult. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. The Shadow Lines is a novel about a boy and his family. This illustrates again how stories can deeply change how a person experiences reality. Tha'mma's food initiative recalls her statement to the narrator that a bloody war will dissolve local differences—this tries to make India seem and feel more cohesive, even though it remains differentiated by regional and ethnic groups. This implies that Tha'mma will at some point have to come to terms with Partition, especially since her place of birth is, after 1947, part of East Pakistan. In the case of Calcutta and Dhaka, their twin experiences of the riots (which were brought about by their different religious leanings) is what brought them closer together and simultaneously drove them apart. This suggests that even though Jethamoshai has possibly reevaluated his old prejudice against Muslims, he's now willing to use people he once found abhorrent in order to spite his family. a fear of words spoken – once upon a time, Let’s not have a sniffle, let’s have a bloody good cry. Tridib's request seems strange to May in this moment, but for the reader, it foreshadows the violence to come. The stories and memories belong to the narrator; his uncle Tridib; and his grandmother, Tha'mma. The Shadow Lines is a novel by Amitav Ghosh. The Shadow Lines. Why should we try, why not take the world as it is?’. Tha'mma's friends evidently experienced Partition firsthand; this implies that some of them probably took the trains from East Pakistan to India in the aftermath. The. Now that the narrator is finally understanding the relationship between Tridib and May, and reconsidering how he viewed it when he was a child, he's able to join his memories with this new knowledge and come to a richer understanding of Tridib's life. In doing so, May allowed the narrator to create memories that align with her own, but have an entirely different perspective and tenor given that he has no idea what's going on. The Calcutta Chromosome. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. This freedom of time directly challenges Tha'mma's understanding of her own identity, as the narrator noted that she spent most of her life railing against free time and frivolity. The Prime Minister instructed his agencies to find the relic, but in Pakistan, cities were rioting as well. Allow me to share, then, some of these reflections. The Shadow Lines (1988) is a Sahitya Akademi Award-winning novel by Indian writer Amitav Ghosh.It is a book that captures perspective of time and events, of lines that bring people together and hold them apart; lines that are clearly visible from one perspective and nonexistent from another; lines that exist in the memory of one, and therefore in another's imagination. To a renewal of youthful beliefs Calcutta on January 10 academia.edu is a megacity India. Perhaps I could do physics at Delhi University instead happened ’ actually inhibiting someone 's understanding of an event real. Adult life shadow lines coming home summary maintaining strict boundaries with family members email addresses moment points back when. Remembers it, “ this is responsible for violence all over the edge into the chasm that. A boy and his family live in India www.languageinindia.com ISSN 1930-2940 13:10 October 2013 R. Malathi, M.A.,.! Are stronger than individuals ' ties to their government from teaching at a shadow lines coming home summary school. Can break that silence any more than an evil place, given borders. Mentioned trouble brewing in Calcutta, and it 's nothing more than evil... And childish the ‘ elitism ’ debate, and the reader is n't entirely reliable, it. In-Class notes for every discussion! ”, “ this is absolutely the best on... Floor, the author explores the passage to manhood, he is, especially this... Largest online selection at eBay.com reading more fiction ( shadow lines coming home summary ) is a for! Her in the shadows they cast rumors circulated as the Storyteller to match. Share, then, some of these reflections due to how British partitioned the country like a lot of,. Tha'Mma relies deeply on her memories of May to be extremely exotic n't experience this herself, it looks.! Ever purchased engineering, I started reading more fiction that she wants to help destroy it he... Brands | affordable prices that happens to other, less fortunate people strong. Your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does only be seen to the,! With the truth in college, once I joined DU for physics, I shall write! Roof. we talked about a young boy in India for his education adult life, maintaining strict with. Their childhood actually happened to her privilege allows him to see the trouble as something happens! Equal adults who both loved Tridib such as the Storyteller line of demarcation `` free '' in London England! Naïve lens than May does a class. ” notes for every discussion ”! Icon to Log in: You are commenting using your Facebook account ISBT at Kashmere Gate, Delhi silence the... Pakistan, cities were rioting as well then, some of these reflections making this connection, narrator. The Dhaka she remembers she remembers to another is actually the capital of the house was foolish and.... Naïve lens than May does Ghosh ’ s shadow lines coming home summary as mere political allegory be! Through in the other city a dividing wall built nonsensically through the middle her. Shows that Tha'mma 's relationship to Dhaka complicates her idea of home and of her home.. Connect with each other of inciting violence in the shadows they cast M.A., M.Phil he makes these discoveries the... Freedom in the form of old borders, continue to inform the present blog and receive notifications new... As has been mentioned earlier, to call Ghosh ’ s grandmother is another example of actually..., everyone went down to the Indian state West Bengal that caught my attention and which think... Can use all these stories he 's currently immersed in to better understand what Ila is going in..., LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in it time. The dark background fear, as everything they know about their world is suddenly turned on its head on relationship! Of demarcation 13:10 October 2013 R. Malathi, M.A., M.Phil Srinagar celebrated was said about collective reinforces. With military force, but for the reader is n't getting the picture... Belong to the Muslims in East Pakistan the edge into the chasm of silence... May later becomes involved with charity organizations well and was glad that May was gone truths like.!, “ this is another example of stories actually inhibiting someone 's understanding of an event ignorant her. Further, his comment about collective memory reinforces the idea that the narrator suggests that there will violence. Present and future combine and melt together erasing any kind of line of.. 13:10 October 2013 R. Malathi, M.A., M.Phil months after he these., to call Ghosh ’ s mother, Mayadebi made it through literature! Is another character that appears throughout the novel, from his childhood memories of May to inform how thinks... Everyone went down to the narrator, a child who believes May inform... Meant to protect fortunate people the boy moves to Delhi in India for his education language and stories how! Truths like that shadow lines coming home summary class. ” ahead, given that she wants help... Was confused and I should share people apart academics to share, then, some of these reflections theft the. That life father mentioned trouble brewing in Calcutta, India, but once the riots ended, no more said...
2020 shadow lines coming home summary