Jump to content
Whatbird Community


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by okaugust

  1. Oh sure, make me feel old, but I appreciate the help, even if it is almost two years later. ?
  2. Taken May 12th, 2019, at Goldeneye/Burlington Reservoir, west of Casper, WY. There had been reports of at least one Short-billed Dowitcher in the mix, but every time I try to work out any possible differences, I'm at a bit of a loss. Long-billed are the norm out here. Recent posts on various facebook bird groups made me get them out and look again, with the same results. I'm wondering if anyone else can spot something I don't have the skills to work out, and find a Short-billed in the photos. If so, what markers? Thank you! 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) ? 8 9 10 About the time I think one or the other has slightly different characteristics, I talk myself out of it by finding more similarities. Probably just wishful thinking on my part. Thank you again!
  3. Thanks all! To be honest, I've posted a few times with just a bird or two and sometimes don't even get a response. I wondered if maybe people see the title or one bird and think they don't know gulls, or flycatchers, and just move on without even looking sometimes. I know with my limited skills in those areas, I would. I've had better luck with a larger bunch of birds to ID in general than just one or two. But I'll take that into account next time. I will dig through the answers and see if I can tweak the IDs a bit more. Again, many thanks! I've been working six days a week, and that's taken a lot of steam out of birding all summer, and I just don't feel as sharp, so I appreciate your input all the more.
  4. Awesome, thanks again so much both of you! It really drives me nuts to get stumped on birds I see commonly. I'd love the idea of a Yellow-bellied Flycatcher too, except it sounded just like a Least, tchbeck! LOL
  5. LOL, if it helps, I have 9,252 photos in eBird, and have only been birding since 2013. It's really helped me with comparisons, and also because my older eyes are just not very good at seeing things up in the trees and so on. And of those 9k photos, right now I only need help with this many! Whew! Thank you, I'll go make some corrections and ponder a bit more on those that seem to be good! I really do appreciate it!
  6. I've had a few bird photos that I seem to have misidentified on eBird, and they've been flagged as unconfirmed. Even a few that the eBird reviewer and I have already reviewed again and confirmed again. Most I'm just struggling with and I've been working six days a week, my head is spinning, so I thought I would go to ask the audience and see if anyone had any other opinions or help to offer. It is much appreciated! 1) I IDd as Song Sparrow. It was taken two weeks ago at 7500 feet in the Bighorn Mountains, eastern side, Hunters Creek area. 2) July 5th, 2019 Taken along Little Firehole, WY south of Rock Springs. There is a little tiny canyon along a road that boasts Virginia's Warblers. The song was spot on for a VIWA, but I'm wondering if the photo is actually a Yellow Warbler upon closer review. 3 ) July 3, 2019 - Baby Lakes trail/meadow in the Medicine Bow-Routt National Forest, south central WY. 8800' in elevation. There were a few swallow like birds flying over head, but not close enough or in the trees to see what. Found this call on a nest, and thought Tree Sparrow. Maybe not? 4) July 1, 2019, Hutton Lake NWR, south of Laramie, WY. Baird's Sandpiper, but admittedly, the sandpipers (and flycatchers and gulls) are my nemesis for ID it seems. 5) June 1, 2019, Sheridan, WY along Little Goose Creek. Lack of eye ring and typical behavior of a Western Wood Pewee, but I guess not correct there either. It really has too much white on the wing bar, and maybe the eye ring is just faint, possible Least? 6) May 11, 2019, Scott Bicentennial Park - Dayton WY, I had it down for a Northern Rough-winged Swallow. There were two groups of swallows, and this one was high up in the tree so the light was a little tricky. Bank maybe, by the chest patch? 7) a, b, c, d, e - back to the peeps, April 24, 2019, Salt Plains NWR in OK. I put all in is Baird. a b) c) d) e) 8 ) and back to flycatchers. These are the three I'm fairly sure my eBird reviewer (one I know for sure) has already cleared. June 5, 2018, Brinton Rd in Bighorn WY. Willow? a) b) 9) August 30, 2018, Sheridan, WY, Little Goose Creek. eBird reviewer says the eye ring should be good for a Least Flycatcher, but someone has gone in and unconfirmed it no less than three times. I would love to know what they think it is. Since I can't get that, I want to know what you think it is! 10) a, b, c Tom Thorn/Beth Williams WHMA, WY, which is sort of in the middle of nowhere, a great little riparian area in the forest, but not super high elevation. I don't know why these sparrows are kicking my butt here. The eye line I think should be Chipping, or maybe White Crowned, but that doesn't fit the chest speckling. Aug 18, 2018. Then obviously we might have two different species here. a) b) It could just be they were fledglings and the speckling is throwing me off. c) because I think I originally went with White Crowned, got unconfirmed, went with Chipping, got unconfirmed... 11) Finally, what I originally IDd as a Ruby-crowned Kinglet due to the size, yellow coloring, white eye-ring, by beak looks to be some kind of vireo instead. We get Red-eyed and Warbling, but this one doesn't fit that really, so I thought I better be sure and ask for advice. I have to admit, it is sometimes discouraging to know I'm wrong and not be able to put my finger on what it is I'm looking at, quite clearly. I guess if .01% of what I put in eBird I misidentify, I'm probably doing pretty good, but my OCD doesn't allow for that. Thanks again in advance, any IDs I get here will help me with accurate data, and I appreciate it! T
  7. eBird did too, for both Palm and Warbling Vireo! Thanks for the great help!
  8. Oops! Thanks, well, maybe we'll see what the eBird reviewer comes back with. ?
  9. Thank you for the help, very much! I'll submit the three, and see if the Palm clears the rare designation. Also will take a look at the Warbling Vireo as a contender for the second. I found a Bell's Vireo today at another state park, so getting out in the cooler temps and wet weather was worth it!
  10. Visiting my home state of Oklahoma for birdin....er a wedding, and I've got a few birds I'd like to confirm check the ID on or need help with. I may have been born here and grown up here, but I'm out of my birding element for sure, not having done it when I used to live here. These were all taken at the Salt Plains NWR, the peeps out on Sandpiper Trail, the warblers ? on a woods/lakeside trail up in the trees, Eagle Roost Trail. eBird tells me the warblers that should be here right now are: Black-and-white, Yellow, Prothonotary, Orange-crowned, Nashville, Yellow-rumped, Wilson's, Common Yellowthroat and Northern Parula. But as we know, during migration all bets are off. The first one I'm leaning toward Orange-crowned, with the full yellow underside and the faint eye line. But the possible streaking also brings to mind Palm. 1. 2. Lack of any coloring or streaking, I was wondering Lucy's, but the faint eye line and no eye ring...maybe I'm looking at something that's not a warbler, though the tail tells me otherwise... Finally, two peeps that are likely either Baird's or Least, but I'd like to rule out White-rumped (which I've never seen before) or the remote chance of a Western. 3. 4. Well, darn it, it's raining today, so do I go hang out with relatives or go get soaked and bird anyway? I think we all know the answer....thank you in advance for assistance! T
  11. Turning on reply notifications, sees to not be working for me on the top option so trying in response.
  12. LOL Thanks for the back up on the WWPW, I sure wish when someone flags your photos as not what you think that they could attach a notice and email about what they think it is and why. Otherwise it ends up being sort of a head scratcher sometimes. We have some amazing eBird reviewers, but being in the least populated state seem to suffer in backlog as we have very few of them. Whenever something pops up months later suddenly unconfirmed I try to figure it out myself instead of waiting. Flycatchers though, ugh! Other emphids we get here, we get Dusky but usually only in spring (May) and fall (Sept). Least and WWPW all summer. Cordilleran up in elevation a bit west of here in the summer and down below in late spring. Also Willow and Hammonds in spring and early summer, with a very occasional Olive Sided. Thank you for the comments!
  13. The wren is a Bewick's Wren I believe. The photos 1 and 7 I'm going with Western Kingbirds.
  14. Some kind soul went through eBird and unconfirmed one Least Flycatcher and a few of my Western Wood Pewee and photos. WWPW sort of a go to out here in Wyoming, and I usually hear the tell tale call along with the sighting, but I will admit some of these both myself and my local Audubon pres were a little stumped at the time. I opted for WWPW at the time, but remember wondering if it was something else. I've since slept and drank a few times though, so don't remember the call to go with it. The minutia of flycatchers stumps me sometimes, especially in February when I'm months out on seeing these little fellows. Help is greatly appreciated! This one was at Tower Falls in Yellowstone, May 2018 1) These were all along Brinton Road in Big Horn, WY, July 2018, on the same day. The area has a lot of trees, riparian, some hay fields and horses properties. 2) 3) & 4) same bird 5) 6) 7) Maybe a Olive-sided Flycatcher? 8. 9) 10) This is the one I IDd as Least, because it was calling the Least call. I remember this one and its call clearly because I was so happy to have the call to go with the bird. Unless another was in the area and this one just was doing an act with it.... It was taken late August, 2018 in the Powderhorn neighborhood between Sheridan and Big Horn, WY, along a riparian, brushy area. Again, thanks in advance! Hope your winter birding is going well. It's been very mild, but now cold here. Not much real snow down here, though the mountains seem to be getting it pretty well. We went to Bosque del Apache NWR last weekend to shake the winter fatigue, and now we're back here hoping for spring! Tina
  15. My limited use of binoculars is usually when someone hands them to me, I try to use them, and I get sort of nauseous. I know that sounds weird...but it's been that way ever since I was a kid. Maybe it's just never having a good pair, or a pair that is dialed in for me, but I also almost never wear sunglasses for the same reason. My eyes were so nearsighted before I got lasik about 17 years ago, that I couldn't even read the big E on the chart without them. Now I have pretty good vision still following the lasik, but the best way I can explain is it feels like my eyes are so used to focusing on the closest things that they still focus on the near things like glasses or binoculars instead of the thing I'm trying to look through it at. I also don't use my viewfinder on the camera for the same reason. That's pretty much instant headache. I also have a shunt in my brain in the last five years, so that might contribute to the oogy feeling too. I don't know. I'm a mess? I wonder if I could get away with a scope, but I suspect I don't want to spend the money on a great one and wouldn't drag it along with me half the time if I did. I've also only been really birding about the last five years, so I don't trust myself 100% yet to register what I'm actually seeing. I like to get it home and study it. Which is what I'm doing tonight with the zillion dang gulls I found today. But also found a Great Egret and a late Western Tanager, so I got that going for me! ? The first photo, I've pondered the coloring people are seeing, but my focus I think is stuck on the bills, which look shorter and very cupped too me. Too short for shovelers, too cupped for wigeon. But then, I can't tell what they are myself, so you all could be quite right! The last one...Godwit, that's intriguing, I'll do some comparing with my bird books when I get home. I'm on the road today going from Sheridan, WY to the Denver metro area in a rental car, and it drives me batty to leave my mobile library behind! Keep the ideas coming, I love them, and it gives me something to learn from! Thank you!
  16. Thanks both of you! Still hopeful for a few more guesses. The loon was wishful thinking, and thank you for the swamp sparrow confirm, that's a bird I've only seen once before, and never in Wyoming! I usually get better pictures....I don't trust my old eyes really and binocs don't work very well for my used to be very near sighted vision for some reason. But it never fails, the shot that is lousy is going to have a surprise bird in it I can't figure out!
  17. Was out and about today in northern Wyoming following getting about 3-5" of snow yesterday. It pushed a lot of waterfowl our way, which is exciting. Some migrants hidden in with the regular suspects. I have, I think, three scoters here. But what scoters? All three can be found, though rarely, migrating through Wyoming. It was a long shot and not very clear. Healy Reservoir, Johnson County WY Lake DeSmet, and it's not unusual at this time of year to have Common Loons. On top of being a far off shot again, and it never came up in view again, the glare was really something. Odds are on a Common Loon, but it's a little less beaky and black and white than I'm used to seeing, so looking for other opinions. Back at Healy, which was much more dried up from last week, where I was lurking among the reeds and standing in the mud, being part of the scnery when a lovely Sora came out and walked around me, I also got this sparrow, which I think might be a swamp? While I'm at it, for the bonus round, 10.14.18 at a pond east of Buffalo WY, I diagnosed as a Short Billed Dowitcher, which is unusual around here. I'm not 100% comfortable with that, thinking it might be wishful thinking on my part. Any thoughts? Thanks much! I really try to get my eBird reports in correctly, and appreciate the expert advice. T
  18. Thanks Tony, most appreciated! It feels good to at least be in the ballpark!
  19. Bad light. Very bad light. And bad distance. I know they may not be IDable, but I thought it was worth a shot. Getting some good migrants now, so I'm reluctant to make a call on unfamiliar birds. A couple of weeks ago I spotted a rare to Wyoming Buff-breasted Sandpiper, so I'm a little snap happy right now hoping for other surprises. Help is appreciated! First one was in an almost dried up very small pond area in Sheridan, WY. The pond supports a few Red-winged Blackbirds, House Wren, ducks over the summer. Cattails and willows are good spots for migrants in the fall, but hard to get in the fall light. I see darker grey on lighter gray, and maybe an eye ring, and it was making a deep CHCK call, like a Common Yellowthroat. There is almost a touch of blue at the end of the wings, but I think that's just the light maybe. Second is also from Sheridan, also tonight, flitting around the trees at the edge of the golf course and middle of the fairway. Also making a loud CHCK warbler call note. With the streaking underneath, the facial coloring and eye ring, I was considering Black and White Warbler, but it wasn't moving along the trunk as I would expect it to. I've tried to lighten the photo and so on, but without much luck. Finally, taken last weekend at a pond near Buffalo WY, the usual gang of hard to see miscreants. I'm thinking left to right, Wilson's Phalarope, Long Billed Dowitcher, Wilson's Phalarope, Greater Yellowlegs. A couple more closer shots below, but this is sort of the clearest. This one seems to have a rather downward curving bill Or could the Phalaropes be Stilt Sandpiper perhaps? Closer shot And just for fun, the Buff-breasted Sandpiper, first eBird reported, fourth in the state with game and fish! Really exciting! Not all of my photos are completely lousy either, I promise!
  20. Lovely! I haven't seen one of those in about a year! Looking back at my last photos, the wing bars and tail match. Thank you so much!
  21. These were taken midafternoon at Edness K Wilkins State Park in Casper, WY. The coloring and wing bars make me think some type of flycatcher, but the behavior wasn't what I'm used to seeing. We still have a lot of Western Wood Pewees about, but there were two of these, small, not very upright like the pewee, going tree to tree, and the trees were smaller, shrub trees, not like the big cottonwoods that the pewees like to use the dead branches of. They were sticking close to the leaves, and had an almost very light cat like mew call. They were also very quick and didn't sit still, almost more like a warbler, in movement. We have migrants coming through now, like Wilson's Warbler and Swainson's Thrush, which I know are not this bird, but this could be just something I don't usually see or hear. Any suggestions are appreciated! Thank you very much!
  22. I've been checking our new IBA east of Buffalo, WY, and we've picked up some great birds out there including Sprague's Pipit, Cassin's Sparrow, Clay Colored Sparrow and Chestnut Collared Longspurs. Along with these there are a good amount of Grasshopper Sparrows, Brewer's Sparrows, Vesper Sparrows, Horned Larks and Lark Buntings. I found these birds in the same batch of sage and grass as the Cassin's, and I originally IDd them as Brewer's. However, that got flagged as incorrect, so I thought I would put it out there. Young sparrows are driving me batty this summer, to the point where I get excited followed by, "oh no, another sparrow to ID!" They are all pics of the same 2 or 3 birds. I think my logic is telling me it's too much good fortune for them to ALL be Cassin's, which are unusual out here. Thank you! 1. 2. I think is the same bird as 1. 3. Possible another Cassin's? 4. 5. Has two birds in it, a good size comparison. Not 100% sure on either bird.
  23. Out east of Buffalo WY, on the prowl for Sprague's Pipit, which we recorded five days prior, but have not spotted. This is grass land along a dirt road, with sage brush in the vicinity and a few low lying ponds not too far away. In an effort to further document the Pipit, I took a photo of every LBB I crossed paths with, and I think I'm about sparrowed out trying to ID them all. Help here is mucho appreciated. We have Western Meadowlarks, and Horned Larks here, a lot of them, and Chestnut Collared Longspur. Lark Bunting, Grasshopper Sparrow, Brewer's Sparrow all in the neighborhood. Occasional Clay Colored Sparrow. This is a new IBA for our local Audubon, over 20k acres, and so I'd like to make sure we record everything we can, and correctly, as the land owner is very interested in sensitive species. I think the bill rules out the Pipit on these, but I wanted to make sure with some other opinions. 1) I think juvenile Horned Lark... 2) Maybe female Longspur? 3) Looks a lot like two but does not have the white edges on the wings. 4) Thank you in advance for any IDs and tips and tricks on these guys. ?
  • Create New...