Jump to content
Whatbird Community


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by smittyone@cox.net

  1. Smitty's bored, so he's taking you down a rabbit hole with him. I get two subspecies of White-crowned Sparrows in my area--Gambel's and Dark-lored. I can pretty easily ID them both when they're adults. But here's where it gets sticky. I also get first winter ones here as well. Are there other features, besides with or without dark lores, I can use (on first winter birds) to distinguish between Gambel's and Dark-lored? I don't know if the stripe between the eye and bill is faint on a first winter bird, or non-existent for both subspecies, or what. If it's not possible to tell them apart when they're young, then I'm OK with just calling them first winter WCSP. But if there are other features I should be looking for, well... All of the pics below were taken in western Iowa in January. The first 3 pics were taken in one location (they all could be the same bird, I don't remember). The remaining pics were all taken at a second western Iowa location on a different day. I also don't remember if they were all the same bird or not. If I were to guess, I'd say the first 3 were Gambel's and the rest are Dark-lored.
  2. Grey Ghost seen scanning the farm fields yesterday afternoon in NW Missouri.
  3. "...are you branching out from Red-taileds?" I'm an equal opportunity bird photographer. I prefer raptors, but I'll photograph anything with feathers that'll sit still long enough. Especially ducks. No, warblers. I like 'em all.
  4. I don't know how large their "territory" is, but another Merlin two days later and only 1 1/2 miles away, was ID'd on here as a probable Prairie. However, that bird was bathed in dusk lighting, so the colors could've been misleading.
  5. This bird was seen in western Iowa on 8 January. Adult Merlin is my starting point. Is it a Taiga or a Prairie, male or female? Both Taiga and Prairie are in my area according to eBird. I'm seeing more brownish tones rather than grayish. So I'm leaning towards Prairie.
  6. That works great! Didn't know I could do that. Thanks so much.
  7. aveschapinas, not sure what you mean by my profile page, but after signing in, I select activity, then my activity streams, then content I started. It only goes back as far as 1 Jan 2023, regardless of the date range I select. If I actually try the search function and search by author and put in my name, it only goes back to March 2020 with only 20 entries. I know I joined way before then, and I know I've started more than 20 topics.
  8. Hats off to Jerry and his FB secret weapons who always come through.
  9. Photographed yesterday. I was watching this immature Eastern Red-tailed Hawk sitting on a utility pole. It dove/glided down from the pole to the roadside ditch directly next to my car, perhaps 30 feet away! Although I anticipated this, way too many of my shots cut off wingtips, tail, half the bird... some frames didn't even have a bird in them at all. I even remembered to zoom all the way out from 600 down to 200mm--I usually forget to do this. Photographing birds in flight while seated in a car is tougher than you might think. Many of the pics I managed to keep in frame were not tack sharp. Seems my Sony a9 struggles with fast moving subjects coming towards the photographer.
  10. I used to be able to review content I started from a couple of years ago, but now, I can only go back to 1 Jan 2023, even though I select a date range much farther back than that.
  11. I agree Prairie are lighter than Taiga, but do you have males lighter than females backwards?
  12. Well, I guess I'll have to readdress my previous Merlins since I've been calling them all Taiga, with the lighter ones being females. Dang it.
  13. Any ideas as to whether it's a Prairie or a Taiga? Or does the overall color wash from the setting sun hinder that. According to eBird (who knew they broke out subspecies?), both types are common in my area.
  14. Seen today at sunset near Crescent, Iowa. I believe it's a female Taiga Merlin. But the setting sun made it look very orange. I think the color is what's throwing me off.
  15. Saw this guy this morning near Council Bluffs, Iowa. Is this adult Red-tailed Hawk a Northern or a Western variant? I know you guys love to ID these as much as I love submitting them. As long as it helps others out, I don't mind being too lazy to ID them myself (except the easy ones). I didn't capture any frontal views, so the side view with tail raised will have to do. But I did get the all important upper tail shot. I've got another waiting in the wings after this one gets ID'd.
  16. Thanks so much everyone. Jerry, I cut/pasted your ID info into word, then saved it in my bookmarks. Maybe I won't have to ask you guys questions you've already answered (again). Off topic (sort of). Does anyone know for how long this website archives entries? I regularly go back and re-read bird ID requests I've made here, to compare similar birds. Sometimes that helps me not have to post ID questions. But when I go back too far in the archives, the original posts are missing. Maybe I can save answers to questions I've posted somehow? Suggestions?
  17. I'm glad you guys enjoyed this one. Especially the FB folks. So if I understand correctly, it's a light morph Harlan's? Not intergraded with any other RTHA? Because my stubbornness only recognizes a Harlan's when it's a dark morph, and sometimes an intermediate morph. I guess the reason I can't wrap my brain around a light-morph Harlan's is because I'm stuck on the wrong features that make it a Harlan's. Someone on here, not too long ago, pointed out which features should actually be looking for a Harlan's ID, but I've forgotten and worse, lost that thread. Also, I could start a new thread with the bird below, but because it shares many of the characteristics of the bird we've been discussing, I didn't want to lose any of the comments. This one was seen late yesterday afternoon in western Iowa, about 25 miles north of Tuesday's bird.
  18. Thanks Avery. It doesn't help a novice to try and learn bird ID when a reference is incorrect. Maybe I should be more careful of my sources, and stop using Google to see what pops up.
  19. I can't post the link, but I CAN copy parts of the article. Cackling Goose aka Lesser or Small Canada or Canadian Goose SEPTEMBER 16, 2021 BY TEAM BEAUTY OF BIRDS The Cackling Goose (Branta hutchinsii) occurs in North America, where it is regionally common. This species has adapted well to living in urban and suburban areas and are commonly found on lakes, ponds and rivers. In the past, the Cackling Goose was considered to be a smaller subspecies of the Canada Goose. However, in July 2004, the American Ornithologists’ Union’s Committee split them up into two separate species based on genetic studies and differences in: voice size (most races of Cackling Goose being smaller than the Canada Goose) breeding habitat (Cackling Goose breeds farther northward and westward than the Canada Goose) There are 5 subspecies of Cackling Goose, of varying sizes and plumage details. The smallest form of the Cackling Goose – the Lesser Canada Goose or Small Cackling Goose – is only about a quarter the size of the “Giant Canada Goose.” This goose is easily recognized by its black head and neck, distinctive white patches on the face, light tan to cream chest and its otherwise brownish-grey plumage.
  20. I can't cut/paste the website "Beatutyofbirds.com" that states there's 5 subspecies of Cackling Goose, one of which is also know as Lesser Canada Goose. Now I'm really confused.
  21. Seen yesterday in Council Bluffs, IA. Is the smaller goose facing right a Cackling Goose? Is size the only difference to look for?
  22. Jerry, I'm always happy to allow the FB folks take a look. I have an endless supply of RTHA pics to keep them entertained for a long time.
  23. Any views that show the color of the uppertail coverts? Best I can do. Hope it helps.
  • Create New...