Purple Finch?

[Colton V]

Are the first two photos purple finch? Thought it was a house finch at first but the reddish wings are throwing me off. Also, the last two photos are house finch, right? Just making sure.

[Connor Cochrane]

They both look like HOFI for me. The first bird does seem pretty red, but I think I see streaks and a squared off tail. Hard to tell though 

[Colton V]

Cropped the first bird

[Colton V]

3 minutes ago, Connor Cochrane said:

They both look like HOFI for me. The first bird does seem pretty red, but I think I see streaks and a squared off tail. Hard to tell though 

A few things make me think this is a purple finch. The streaks seem way too faint, as well as the wing bars. The bird also has a lot more red on it. The red extends farther down the chest as well as the wings. 

[akandula]

I agree with Colton. The first bird is a Purple Finch while the second bird is a House Finch.

[Connor Cochrane]

Thanks for cropping the first photo. It’s definitely a purple. 

[Colton V]

Thanks for the confirmation!